Case Report
A 45-year-old male presented with a 20-year history of symptomatic, paroxysmal tachycardias at a rate of approximately 120 bpm, which resolved spontaneously and had not been documented on ECG. During the last two months, he experienced two more severely symptomatic episodes with an ECG appearance compatible with common-type atrioventricular nodal reentrant tachycardia (AVNRT) at a rate of 170 bpm, which were terminated with intravenous adenosine.
An electrophysiological study (EPS) was performed. With atrial extrastimulus pacing, a regular narrow QRS tachycardia was easily induced, with a cycle length (CL) of 522 ms, an HA interval of 134 ms, and eccentric atrial activation at the coronary sinus (CS) 5-6 (Fig. 1A). Using the same pacing protocol, a second regular narrow QRS tachycardia was induced with greater difficulty, demonstrating a cycle length of 360 ms, an HA interval of 52 ms, and earliest atrial activation at the His bundle region, evidently compatible with the ECG-documented common-type AVNRT. This latter tachycardia transitioned to the first form following a critical prolongation of the AH interval (Fig. 1B).
By delivering single ventricular extrastimuli from the right ventricle during the first tachycardia—at a time when the His bundle was refractory—no advancement of atrial activation was observed (Fig. 2A). Conversely, delivering ventricular extrastimuli from the left ventricle resulted in advancement of atrial activation, exhibiting an activation sequence identical to that of the tachycardia (Fig. 2B). This finding is diagnostic of orthodromic atrioventricular reentrant tachycardia (AVRT) involving a concealed left-sided accessory pathway.
Subsequently, ablation of the slow AV nodal pathway was performed, which rendered both tachycardias non-inducible (Fig. 3). Despite the lack of inducibility, we proceeded with ablation of the left-sided accessory pathway via a retrograde approach under continuous ventricular pacing.
Commentary
The uniqueness of this case lies in the fact that an orthodromic AVRT involving a left-sided accessory pathway was eliminated by ablation of the slow AV nodal pathway. The differential diagnosis for this tachycardia includes:
- a) orthodromic atrioventricular reentrant tachycardia involving a left posterolateral accessory pathway,
- b) atrial tachycardia, and
- c) slow-slow atrioventricular nodal reentrant tachycardia with eccentric atrial activation.
Regarding the latter, it has been recognized as a distinct variant of AVNRT, reported in approximately 6% of all AVNRT cases. In this variant, the earliest atrial activation is not observed around the AV node and the interatrial septum as typically seen, but is located eccentrically in the mid or distal region of the coronary sinus. This phenomenon is attributed to atrionodal connections via perinodal transitional cells, which are hypothesized to either constitute part of the AVNRT reentrant circuit or not.
In the present tachycardia, the advancement of atrial activation during tachycardia via a single ventricular extrastimulus delivered while the His bundle is refractory proves the existence of an additional ventriculoatrial connection (accessory pathway), given that ventriculoatrial conduction through the physiological conduction system is impossible during this specific refractory period. The sequence of the advanced atrial activation indicates the site of the atrial insertion of the pathway; if it is identical to that of the tachycardia, it demonstrates that the accessory pathway participates in the reentrant circuit. This diagnostic technique effectively excludes AVNRT and atrial tachycardia.
Frequently, in orthodromic AVRT involving left-sided pathways, advancement of atrial activation cannot be achieved by delivering a ventricular extrastimulus from the right ventricle. This occurs because if the extrastimulus is delivered precisely at the expected time of His bundle recording, transseptal conduction time delays the impulse before it reaches the ventricular insertion of the left-sided accessory pathway. Due to this delay, the atrial activation cannot be advanced. In our case, advancement is not achieved when the extrastimulus is delivered from the right ventricle; instead, a clear advancement of atrial activation by 40 ms is achieved when the extrastimulus is delivered from the left ventricle, specifically from a site close to the presumed ventricular insertion of the pathway, thereby avoiding intraventricular conduction delay.
It is worth noting that many studies addressing slow-slow AVNRT with eccentric atrial activation do not differentiate between ventricular extrastimulus delivery from the right versus the left ventricle—a step that would provide absolute proof of the non-involvement of a left-sided accessory pathway in this variant described as AVNRT. Our case clearly demonstrates how misleading the delivery of ventricular extrastimuli from the right ventricle can be for differential diagnosis. These findings, combined with the fact that the tachycardia was eliminated by slow pathway ablation, could have erroneously led to the conclusion that the mechanism was slow-slow AVNRT with eccentric atrial activation.
Following slow pathway ablation, not only was the AVNRT non-inducible, but the orthodromic AVRT was also rendered non-inducible, despite the fact that the latter was generally more easily induced at baseline. The reason for non-inducibility stems from the increase in the refractory period of the slow AV nodal pathway post-ablation, preventing sufficient prolongation of the AH interval. Such a prolongation would provide the necessary delay allowing the accessory pathway—which possessed a relatively long retrograde refractory period—to recover excitability and conduct retrogradely to sustain orthodromic AVRT (Fig. 3).
Despite the non-inducibility of the tachycardia, we decided to proceed with ablation of the accessory pathway because the AVRT in which it participated had constituted the patient’s clinical problem for years. Furthermore, it could recur if conditions conducive to further delay in anterograde conduction through the physiological system arose (notably, the slow pathway was not completely eliminated) or if, under different conditions outside the laboratory, the retrograde refractory period of the accessory pathway decreased.
The case described herein represents an example of a tachycardia with eccentric atrial activation that was successfully treated via slow pathway ablation, which would be highly "attractive" to attribute to a rare form of slow-slow AVNRT, as has likely occurred in several instances in the literature. However, meticulous electrophysiological evaluation revealed the participation of a concealed accessory pathway in the tachycardia circuit, the definitive ablation of which provides a higher guarantee against recurrence.
Figure Legends
- Figure 1. ECG and intracardiac recordings of the two tachycardias. A: Induction of orthodromic AVRT with a cycle length of 520 ms, VA interval of 90 ms, and eccentric atrial activation at the CS 5-6 bipole, indicated by the arrow on the fluoroscopic LAO projection. Anterograde conduction occurs via the slow pathway and retrograde conduction via the left-sided accessory pathway. B: Transition from slow-fast AVNRT (cycle length: 376 ms) to the first tachycardia following gradual prolongation of the HH interval, driven by a corresponding increase in the AH interval due to critical delay in the slow pathway.
- Figure 2. Single ventricular extrastimuli delivered during tachycardia when the His bundle is refractory. A: Ventricular extrastimulus from the right ventricle failing to advance atrial activation. B: Ventricular extrastimulus from the left ventricle advancing atrial activation by 40 ms with an atrial activation sequence identical to that of the tachycardia, proving the participation of the accessory pathway in the reentrant circuit.
- Figure 3. Non-inducibility of tachycardia post slow pathway ablation. A: At an S₁S₂ coupling interval of 290 ms, conduction occurs via the fast pathway with an AH interval of 80 ms. B: With a 10 ms reduction in the coupling interval, conduction shifts to the slow pathway with an AH interval of 141 ms. This AH prolongation is insufficient to allow recovery of excitability at the ventricular insertion of the accessory pathway and sustain the reentrant circuit. C: Further reduction of the coupling interval to 270 ms results in complete block of the impulse.
References
- Hwang C, Martin DJ, Goodman JS, Gang ES, Mandel WJ, Swerdlow CD, Peter CT, Chen PS. Atypical atrioventricular node reciprocating tachycardia masquerading as tachycardia using a left-sided accessory pathway. J Am Coll Cardiol 1997;30:218 –225.
- Otomo K, Okamura H, Noda T, Satomi K, Shimizu W, Suyama K, Kurita T, Aihara N, Kamakura S. “Left-variant” atypical atrioventricular nodal reentrant tachycardia: electrophysiological characteristics and effect of slow pathway ablation within coronary sinus. J Cardiovasc Electrophysiol 2006;17:1177-1183
- Anselme F, Papageorgiou P, Monahan K, Zardini M, Boyle N, Epstein LM, Josephson ME. Presence and significance of the left atrionodal connection during atrioventricular nodal reentrant tachycardia. Am J Cardiol 1999;83(11):1530–1536.
- Dizon J, Reiffel J, Kassotis J, Woollett I, Garan H. Change in the retrograde atrial activation sequence following radiofrequency modification of the atrioventricular node: Implications for the electrophysiologic circuit of a variant of atrioventricular nodal reentrant tachycardia. J Cardiovasc Electrophysiol 2003; 14:461-466
- Vijayaraman P, Kok LC, Rhee B, Ellenbogen K. Unusual variant of atrioventricular nodal reentrant tachycardia. Heart Rhythm 2005;2:100-102
- Sakabe K, Wakatsuki T, Fujinaga H, Oishi Y, Ikata J, Toyoshima T, Hiura N, Nishikado A, Oki T, Ito S: Patient with atrioventricular node reentrant tachycardia with eccentric retrograde left-sided activation: Treatment with radiofrequency catheter ablation. Jpn Heart J 2000;41:227-234